Menus

Our menu evolves regularly to highlight seasonal ingredients and the freshest catch.

For specific inquiries, don’t hesitate to call.

Oysters

Three / 9.75.

Six / 19.50.

Twelve / 39.00.

Winter 2025

Murder Point

Sandy Bay, AL

Bigger Butters

Sandy Bay, AL

Point Aux Pins

Sandy Bay, AL

Isle Dauphine

Dauphin Island, AL

Surf Dog

Crawfordville, FL

Otters Choice

Spring Creek, FL

Shiny DImes

Spring Creek, FL

Bay Beautes

Skipper Bay, FL

Divine Pine

Topsail Island, NC

Wavelengths

Matheson, VA

Chunu

Smith Island Bay, VA

Ninigret Nectar

Charlestown, RI

Aunt Dotty's

Saquish, MA

Glidden Point

Edgecomb, ME

Farewell Cove

Damariscotta River, ME

Moondancer

Walpole, ME

Eel Lake

Eel Lake, NS

Irish Point

Rustico Bay, PEI

Lucky Charms

Stanhope, PEI

Tidal Treasures

Stanhope, PEI

Hog Island

Tomales Bay, CA

Baywater Indigos

Hood Canal, WA

Wildcat

Hama Hama, WA

Raw Bar

Situations

Oysters, Smoked Mussels, Fish Dip, Shrimp Cocktail

55.

All Day

Hamachi Crudo

24.

Wasabi Ponzu, Kombu Oil

Dry-Aged Ora King Salmon

30.

Horseradish, Cured Egg Yolk, Caperberries, Endive

Tuna Crudo

18.

Coconut Milk, Apple, Celery

Shrimp Toast

16.

Focaccia, Lemongrass, Cilantro

Prawns on Half Shell

28.

Shrimp Butter, Cimichurri, Capers

Red Snapper

34.

Beurre Blanc, Mussel Vinagrette

Tuna Steak

36.

Citrus, Mint, Tarragon

Mahi Mahi

36.

Miso & Egg Sauce, Basmati Rice

Reuben

22.

Swordfish Pastrami, Caraway Slaw, Triple Crown Sauce, Fries

Double with Cheese

22.

Yellowfin Tuna, American Cheese, Lettuce, Dubyah Sauce, Fries

Mushrooms Skewers, Tare, Labneh, Sunchokes

16.

Oysters & Jimmy Red Grits, Bourbon, Brown Butter

16.

Grilled Cabbage, Anchovy Vinaigrette, Breadcrumbs

12.

Sweet Potatoes, Roe XO, Horseradish Dressing

14.

Hand Cut Fries, Garlic Aioli

10.

Coconut Creme Pie

12.

Lemon Pistachio Cake

14.

Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream

10.

Drinks

Cocktails

Boxing Day

13.

Ketel One Vodka, Cranberry & Rosemary, Creme de Cacao, Lemon

Hay Is For Horses

14.

Citadelle Rouge, Alpeggio, Dolin Chamberyzette, Christmas Tree Syrup

It's Like Butter, Baby

14.

Brown Butter Washed Four Roses, Maple, Orange & Chocolate Bitters

Oaxacan Winter

13.

Montelobos, Cappalletti, Ancho Reyes, Spices, Lime

Not My Gumdrop Buttons

16.

Oat Infused Hayman's, Gingerbread Syrup, Domaine Canton, Lemon

Hans Gruber's Retirement Plan

15.

Planteray Cut & Dry, Warre's Otima, Pineapple & Coffee, Cappalletti, Lime

Espresso Patronum

15.

Coffee Washed Wheatley Vodka, Simple Syrup

ITS A CLEAR CHOICE

Martini Service

Peppermint Tease

16.

Rumple Minze, Chambord, Frangelico

Citrus Mistress

18.

Hayman's Citrus, Lillet Blanc

The Bayonet Martini

20.

Gray Whale Gin, Carpano Dry, Oyster

IF YOU COULD KISS A MERMAID. CRAFTED TABLESIDE.

Sparkling

NV CLAVELIN CREMANT DU JURA

12.

Jura, France.

NV Castel Pujol 'Folklore' Pet-Nat

13.

CARRO CHAPEU, UY

NV GERARD BERTRAND 'FRENCH CANCAN' SPARKLING ORANGE WINE

17.

Loire Valley, France

NV Scarpetta 'Timido' Sparkling Rose

12.

Friuli, IT

White

2023 Lingua Franca Chardonnay

17.

WILLAMETTE VALLEY, OR

2023 Meyer-Fonne 'Gentil' (Off-Dry) White Blend

13.

Alsace, Fr

2024 Dominio Del Urogallo Field Blend

13.

Asturias, ES

2022 Pojer Sandri 'Palai' Muller Thurgau

15.

Tentino - Alto Adige. IT

2022 Alexander Zahel Orange Traube

14.

Vienna, AT

2024 Vollenweider 'Felsenfest' Riesling

14.

Mosel, GR

2024 Stolpman Vineyards 'Unfiltered' Sauvignon Blanc

15.

Ballard County, CA

2023 San Simeon Viognier

12.

Paso Robles, CA

Red

2022 Corazon Del Sol Cabernet Franc

17.

Uco Valley, AR

2001 Voche "Vino de Autor

16.

Rioja, Spain

2022 Resonance Pinot Noir

16.

WILLAMETTE VALLEY, OR

2024 La Mongestine 'Bob Singlar' Red Blend

12.

Vin de France

2024 'Folly' by Mascaronne Gernache Rose

11.

Cotes De Provence, FR

Beer

ALABAMA LIGHT

7.

B Nektar Chai Cider

10.

Hitachino White Ale

10.

Straight To Ale Domo Arigato

7.

Yellowhammer Dark Hammer Belgian Quad

10

Yellowhammer Mic Czech

7.

Sierra Nevada Trail Pass NA

6.